Cookie and Ice Cream Made from Scratch
Place an order through our online order form above. We use Square as our order platform and accept most major credit and debit card companies.
Pickup is at 62 Wharf St. Salem, MA on Thursdays from 6 pm - 7 pm, Fridays from 6 pm - 7 pm, Saturdays from 12 pm - 1:30 pm and Sundays from 11 am - 12 pm. Local deliveries are Sundays only, 9 am - 12:30 pm.
You can also walk in during our pick up hours to purchase a Witch Wich. We are located inside Salem Spice, just come in and ask for Witch Wich!
Witch Wich Salem is co-founded by two residents of Salem, Massachusetts; a place we love and care for deeply. We are hardworking young adults that want to bring something new and special to Salem. We are passionate about the community and believe that Witch Wich Salem can unite the Salem community, and beyond.
The two main components of an Ice Cream Sandwich are simply Ice Cream and Cookies. Alone, they are delicious, but together, they make a pretty incredible team. What makes Witch Wich unique from a traditional Ice Cream Sandwich is the chocolate. The chocolate acts as a binding agent for the Ice Cream Sandwich, keeping the ice cream and cookie intact, all while adding a layer of deliciousness. The combination of the three makes an extraordinary trifecta that when together, makes the cookie stronger. Just like the Witch Wich, when we work together, we are stronger.
We have put many hours into perfecting the Witch Wich recipe. We make everything from scratch and by hand; the gooey chocolate chip cookie, the rich and creamy vanilla bean ice cream, and import the finest chocolate from Belgium. Stay tuned for where we pop-up in Salem!
A homemade chocolate chip cookie ice cream sandwich, with homemade vanilla bean ice cream, coated in gourmet semi-sweet chocolate
A homemade chocolate chip cookie ice cream sandwich, with homemade vanilla bean ice cream
A mini version of our Original Witch Wich- homemade vanilla bean ice cream, in between two homemade chocolate chip cookies, drenched in gourmet chocolate , on a stick
A mini version of our Basic Witch, homemade vanilla bean ice cream, in between two homemade chocolate chip cookies, on a stick
Homemade, Apple Pie Ice Cream, made with a blend of fresh, locally picked Macintosh and Granny Smith Apples, in between classic, chewy, oatmeal cookies.
**please note this is a specialty item and is not available all the time
Our take on a cinnamon roll - our classic vanilla bean ice cream in between cinnamon-swirled cookies, drizzled with icing
**please note this is a specialty item and is not available all the time
Homemade, strawberry Ice cream, made with fresh local strawberries, in between our classic chocolate chips cookies, drenched in gourmet chocolate and sprinkled with granulated honey
**please note this a speciality product and is not available all the time
Homemade, strawberry Ice cream, made with fresh local strawberries, in between our classic chocolate chips cookies, sprinkled with granulated honey
**please note this a specialty item and is not available all the time
Decadent, homemade Mint Chip Ice Cream, in between two chewy “Inside Out” Chocolate Chip Cookies - white chocolate chips, inside a chocolate base cookie
**this is a specialty product and not available at all times
Homemade Mint Chip Ice Cream, in between our classic chocolate chip cookies, drenched in gourmet chocolate
**this is a specialty product and is not available at all times
Homemade Mint Chip Ice Cream, in between our classic chocolate chip cookies
**this is a specialty product and is not available at all times
Your favorite summer treat in an Ice Cream Sandwich! Marshmallow, Graham Cracker, and Hershey's Ice Cream in between our classic Chocolate Chip cookie, drizzled with Hershey's Chocolate and dusted with Graham Crackers
**this is a specialty product and is not available at all times
Homemade, gooey, sea salt caramel, layered between the classic Witch Wich chocolate chip cookies and vanilla bean ice cream, sprinkled with Hawaiian Black Salt
**this is a specialty product and is not available all the time
Homemade, gooey, sea salt caramel, layered between the classic Witch Wich chocolate chip cookies and vanilla bean ice cream
**this is a specialty product and is not available all the time
Toasted Coconut Ice Cream, in between chocolate chip cookies, coated in Toasted Coconut
**this is a specialty product and not available at all times
Toasted Coconut Ice Cream, in between chocolate chip cookies, coated in chocolate and sprinkled with Toasted Coconut
**this is a specialty product and not available at all times
A mini version of our Basic Witch, homemade vanilla bean ice cream in between two homemade chocolate chip cookies, on a stick, with sprinkles
A mini version of our Basic Witch, homemade vanilla bean ice cream in between two homemade chocolate chip cookies, on a stick, with sprinkles
The classic Witch Wich cookies, without all the extras
In addition to our weekend hours, you can find us at these pop-ups!
We’re back at Far From the Tree!
314 Essex Street, Salem, MA 01970
Join us at the JPaul Saturday afternoon and night! The JPaul is located to the left of the famous Witch House in Salem! We will be there a...
314 Essex Street, Salem, MA 01970
Email us at witch.wichsalem@gmail.com for more information on catering. Custom Witch Wich's are $1 extra per sandwich. We can also cater any flavor, regardless of whether we have it in stock or not. Please place custom order at least one week in advance. No order minimum or maximum.
Please reach us at witch.wichsalem@gmail.com if you cannot find an answer to your question.
62 Wharf St, Salem, MA! We are located inside Salem Spice! Just come in and ask for Witch Wich.
Right now, we are only fulfilling orders on the Thursdays, Fridays and the weekend, due to the nature of the product and to ensure its freshness. We suggest that you place an soon as we restock on Thursday's as we make a limited number of Witch Wich's every week and once they are gone, you will have to wait until the following weekend to get your order.
We accept credit and debit, cash or venmo. Our venmo username is @witchwichsalem.
Sign up to hear from us about discounts and special events.
62 Wharf Street, Salem, Massachusetts 01970, United States
Open today | 06:00 pm – 07:00 pm |
Your support and contributions will enable us to meet our goals and develop new products. Your generous donation will fund our mission.
Copyright © 2022 Witch Wich Salem - All Rights Reserved.
Powered by GoDaddy
We use cookies to analyze website traffic and optimize your website experience. By accepting our use of cookies, your data will be aggregated with all other user data.